Introduction

The Lumbee Indians are one of the most remarkable Indigenous communities in the United States—resilient, deeply rooted, and determined. Centered in southeastern North Carolina around the winding Lumber River, they are the largest tribe east of the Mississippi and among the most culturally unique Native groups in the nation. Yet, despite their size, history, and well-documented identity, the Lumbee Indians have spent more than a century fighting for one thing many tribes already possess: full federal recognition.

This is the story of the Lumbee Indians, their origins, and the reasons behind their long struggle for recognition, which is one of the most compelling civil rights battles of our time.

Origins of the Lumbee Indians

The history of the Lumbee Indians dates back long before the United States was established. Archaeological evidence indicates that Indigenous peoples have inhabited what is now Robeson County, NC, for at least 14,000 years. Over centuries, Siouan-speaking groups such as the Cheraw and Keyauwee, along with other Southeastern tribes, mingled and settled within the wetland river environment surrounding the Lumber River.

Families with names like Locklear, Oxendine, Chavis, Hunt, and Lowry formed a distinct, self-governing Native community well before the era of Jim Crow. The Lumbee Indians developed a culture rooted in kinship, land, Christian faith, community schools, and mutual support. Even in a complex tri-racial region shaped by Indigenous, African, and European populations, the Lumbee Indians maintained a coherent identity that persisted through social upheaval, segregation, and political exclusion.

State Recognition and the Lumbee Identity

North Carolina formally recognized the Lumbee Indians (then known as the Croatan Indians) in 1885. This designation paved the way for the establishment of their own schools, culminating in the creation of the Croatan Normal School in 1887, which eventually became the University of North Carolina at Pembroke.

In 1953, the state officially adopted the name “Lumbee” based on the Lumber River—a symbol of the people who had thrived along its banks for generations. Throughout the 20th century, the Lumbee Indians established churches, civic organizations, and a strong identity firmly rooted in shared history and cultural pride.

One of the most iconic events in Lumbee history occurred in 1958: the Battle of Hayes Pond. When the Ku Klux Klan attempted to rally near Maxton, NC, hundreds of Lumbee Indians confronted them and shut the event down. The standoff remains a defining moment of bravery and community unity.

The 1956 Lumbee Act: Recognition Without Benefits

In 1956, Congress passed the Lumbee Act, acknowledging the Lumbee Indians by name—but denying them federal benefits, services, and a formal government-to-government relationship enjoyed by other federally recognized tribes. The Act explicitly stated that nothing in it made the Lumbee Indians eligible for federal Indian services.

This unusual halfway status placed the tribe in a bureaucratic limbo: recognized yet not fully recognized. It also blocked the Lumbee Indians from accessing critical resources such as Indian Health Service programs, housing assistance, educational funding, and federal protections for tribal sovereignty.

Why Full Federal Recognition Matters

For the Lumbee Indians, full recognition is not merely symbolic; it is a matter of historical fact. It determines whether the tribe can:

• Access Indian Health Service care (Robeson County has some of the nation’s worst health outcomes)
• Protect and administer tribal lands
• Qualify for federal housing, cultural preservation, and education programs
• Establish a clear legal and political relationship with the U.S. government
• Strengthen economic development opportunities
• Protect their cultural institutions and future generations

With more than 50,000 enrolled members, the Lumbee Indians are one of the largest tribes in the U.S.—yet one of the few of their size without federal recognition.

A Century-Long Struggle

The Lumbee Indians have been pursuing recognition since the 1880s. Over the last century:

• Petitions were filed in 1888
• Federal investigators reviewed their history in the early 1900s
• Multiple congressional bills were introduced throughout the 20th century
• The Lumbee Act blocked administrative recognition routes
• The House of Representatives has approved recognition bills several times
• The Senate has repeatedly failed to act

Political disagreements, budget concerns, and opposition from some federally recognized tribes have complicated the process. These challenges have created one of the longest, most contentious recognition battles in U.S. history.

The Modern Push Toward Recognition

In recent years, support for the Lumbee Indians has grown:

• Multiple U.S. Presidents have publicly endorsed their recognition
• Bipartisan bills have moved through Congress
• The Trump White House issued a presidential action stating the Lumbee are recognized by the state and calling for a plan to secure full recognition
• The tribe has strengthened its government, cultural programs, and economic efforts
• UNC Pembroke continues to be a major cultural and educational anchor for the Lumbee community

Still, full recognition remains just out of reach.

Why the Lumbee Story Matters to America

The story of the Lumbee Indians is more than a tribal issue—it is a lesson in American identity, resilience, and the pursuit of justice.

It reveals how identity adapts:
The Lumbee Indians defy narrow definitions of Native identity, demonstrating how culture endures through community action, not just language retention or bureaucratic documentation.

It exposes political barriers:
Recognition is as much about politics and money as it is about Indigenous heritage.

It highlights overlooked history:
Eastern tribes often receive less attention, yet their stories are just as deep, complex, and meaningful.

It demonstrates resilience:
Despite oppression, segregation, and legal ambiguity, the Lumbee Indians built schools, preserved families, maintained culture, and asserted their rights.

Conclusion: A People Waiting for Justice

Today, the Lumbee Indians remain a proud and thriving community with a rich cultural heritage and a strong tribal government. However, until full federal recognition is granted, their fight will continue.

For a tribe whose ancestors survived colonization, racial categorization, and exclusion, recognition is more than a government decision—it is a long-overdue affirmation of identity, sovereignty, and dignity.

The Lumbee Indians have waited generations for that justice. Whether the federal government finally delivers it will speak volumes about America’s commitment to fairness and to honoring its promises to Indigenous peoples.

Join the Proud Boys: If you’re a man, agree with our 12 tenets, and want to apply to be a Proud Boy, apply now. Your race and nationality are unimportant.